Crime and small business

The Federation of Small Business has asked me to respond and I am keen to commit to supporting small business against the threat and reality of crime.  It is not acceptable for small businesses to become nonviable in the face of uncontrolled crime against them.

I said

…I do think that the risk and the actuality of crime affects small business even more than large chains of convenience stores which have the built in resilience of size.  In addition, independent local business provides valuable diversity and interest to threatened high streets and district centres.

To read the full text of the exchange of email messages please follow the link below.

.fsb

Business Crime

I have responded to a request from the Association of Convenience Stores.  They are, rightly, concerned about the threat caused by crime against their members.

I said

Thank you for writing to me about the impact of business crime on convenience stores.

I believe that convenience stores are an essential part of the “glue” that holds our neighbourhoods together.  The stores serve an important role in the supply chain for food and other goods, but in addition they help sustain a perception and reality of community.  Having vital local shops within walking distance reduces the need To travel and thence reduces car dependency and damage to our environment.

To see the full email exchange, follow the link below.

convenience-stores

Towards a new plan for policing

The Commissioner is required to publish a “Police and Crime Plan” which sets out the priorities for Merseyside Police and the strategy for working to achieve them.  The current Plan is here.

There is not much to disagree with in this Plan and my approach would be to continue the process of evolving it, but with the inclusion of the missing key priority to reduce road traffic crimes, particularly excessive speeds.

I would like to see if the Plan could be made shorter, a bit less general and have more quantitative targets.  I have a concern that the Plan is not known to or used by the general public and few police officers are familiar with it.

Supporting Victims of Crime

The PCC has significant responsibilities for directing a budget for supporting victims which has been transferred from central government.  The current arrangements are set out here.  Again, there is much to agree with.  My approach would be to conduct a review of the way we support and listen to victims, starting with a look at the unpublished consultation report.

Victims of road traffic crashes, many of which have been road traffic crimes, need to be given more consideration by police and the courts.  I am a member of RoadPeace, the national charity which supports these victims.

Neighbourhood Policing

All candidates agree with the importance of strong neighbourhood policing.  It is one of the successes for Merseyside Police.  Pressure on the number of PCSOs has caused them to be spread more thinly on the ground.  Elsewhere I have stated that they should be encouraged to use cycles as preferred transport and to enable them to be visible, covering more ground than is possible if they are always on foot.

I think the Office of the PCC (the team of talented people who work for the PCC) should be asked to see how communication can be improved between neighbourhood policing teams and the population they serve.  One improvement I would like to see is publication of detailed performance data for each neighbourhood.   Local people should be able to see how their area is progressing, over time, and how it compares with other areas.

Building Confidence in Reporting Crime

As a ward councillor, I have often come across people who no longer think it is worthwhile reporting crime or passing on intelligence to the local police.  They may have contacted police in the past, but have not seen a positive outcome and so they become disenchanted: they lack confidence that making a report will make any difference.

The limit on policing resources is always going to mean that positive outcomes cannot be guaranteed, but we need to find ways to report back to local people when they take the trouble  to make a report to the police.

Having a population that is willing always to report crime will have a deterrent effect on those who intend to commit it.

Pro-active Consultation

As well as the (valid) consultation methods already used by the PCC, I think it is important to try to reach the people who do not come forward to respond to invitations to take part in consultations.

I would set up surveys to sample the whole population, borrowing methods from the Crime Survey for England and Wales.  In that way we can reach out to victims of crime who may not have even reported an offence and we can give ourselves a second chance to talk to those who have become disengaged from interacting with the police.

 

 

 

 

South Yorks: should a Commissioner have acted sooner?

Everybody is, rightly, focusing on the courage of the Hillsborough families and their achievement of the truth from the Warrington inquest: 96 people were unlawfully killed; the fans were not to blame.

Today we have seen the welcome action of South Yorkshire PCC in suspending their Chief Constable http://www.southyorkshire-pcc.gov.uk/News-and-Events/News/2016/April/SOUTH-YORKSHIRE-POLICE-CRIME-COMMISSIONER-RESPONDS-TO-HILLSBOROUGH-VERDICTS.aspx

The S Yorks PCC has ample justification in using his authority to suspend this officer.  The police in S Yorks have indeed been brought into disrepute for the way they handled the inquest and pursued their adversarial and false narrative against the football fans.

However, it should have been entirely foreseeable that S Yorks police was heading towards disrepute because of the way it was conducting its case throughout the inquest.  A PCC has no authority to interfere with the “operational independence” of the chief constable, but the management of a legal argument in such an inquest is, surely, not an “operational” matter.

I say this with the luxury of hindsight, but why did the PCC not restrain the chief constable in this case?

And the PCC is himself scrutinised by the Police and Crime Panel?  Did the members of that Panel question the PCC on whether and why he did not intervene and seek to spare the families and the people of Liverpool the anguish of hearing again all those false allegations from the police about the fans’ conduct?

 

 

Rural Crime on Merseyside

Merseyside is predominantly an urban police area with its major city and its towns, but there are important rural areas, including valuable greenbelt, too.

I have had a letter from an organisation called CLA – cla.org.uk – with their five key requests.

  • Tackle theft
  • Stamp out wildlife and heritage crimes
  • Combat fly-tipping
  • Boost police presence
  • Endorse fair funding for rural areas.

I have a great deal of sympathy with these requests.  As a city person, I lack full knowledge of the impact of crime on our adjoining rural areas, but I know urban dwellers appreciate their local countryside and would be willing to see a fair allocation of resources to protect it for all our benefit.

Fraud and Cyber Crime

Now that the election campaign is in full swing, candidates are all receiving requests to endorse or comment on particular manifestos or demands from various sections of society.  This is as it should be.

The link below shows the email exchange with an organisation called CIFAS asking me to respond on the serious matter of fraud and cyber crime.

cifas

P.S. Subsequent email correspondence with another anti fraud organisation, below.

ffauk

PCC Radio Hustings 18th April

Candidates disagree on committing more resources to road traffic law enforcement.

BBC Radio Merseyside hosted an hour-long debate between the four PCC candidates.  To listen to the programme, the link is here.

I thought the debate was useful and constructive, free from some of the ranting that often comes when political opponents clash.  In particular this is the first time I have been in a direct discussion with the current Commissioner Jane Kennedy, although I have been in meetings with her before.  We disagree about some important things and I am seeking to replace her, but I think she is the kind of politician we need more of  in public life.  The other two candidates also have useful things to contribute.

Disagreement on Support for Roads Policing

There is a major difference between a Green Party position on traffic enforcement and the position of my Labour, Lib Dem and Tory opponents and it was made clear in the this debate.  We have seen a declining trend in the numbers of traffic police at the same time as a rising trend in killed and seriously injured road victims on Merseyside.

If elected as PCC, I will have a mandate to do something about the cuts to roads policing.  There may be scope for redistributing resources to restore more effective road traffic policing, but as I have said before, if needed I would propose an increase in the policing precept on the council tax.  Some limited progress is possible by educating drivers and by better engineering, but it is wishful thinking to hope for a solution that does not also involve a credible risk of punishment for drivers who break the law.

Evidence for the retreat from road traffic law enforcement is here .  A committee report this month from Liverpool City Council’s highways officers is quite blunt: “As enforcement decreases, collisions increase…” and  “reduced direct police enforcement (due to reductions in staffing resources) has had a significant impact.”

The national picture is similar.  The loss of police capacity to contain road danger is reported in a House of Commons Transport Select Committee report in March, here.

 

 

 

Candidates and Tax Returns

Mayoral candidate Tom Crone and PCC candidate John Coyne have committed to publish their tax returns.  The press release of 6th April is reproduced below.

Tom Crone’s tax return is here.  John Coyne’s tax return is here.

Press release: Tax Transparency and Earnings Cap

Liverpool Green Party is calling on candidates for the senior positions of Mayor of Liverpool and Mersey Police and Crime Commissioner (PCC) to publish their tax returns now and for each year they hold office, if elected.

Cllr Tom Crone, leader of the Green Party in Liverpool and mayoral candidate said

“I welcome Jeremy Corbyn’s call for tax returns to be published (1) and I hope he follows through on that.  In the 2012 mayoral election, the Green candidate, John Coyne, put his tax return on line (2), but the other candidates did not do so.  If Mayor Anderson had published his tax affairs we would all have known about his undisclosed earnings from Chesterfield High School.  That extra income, from a job he had pledged to give up in 2010 (3), would have been transparent.”

John Coyne who is the Green candidate for Police and Crime Commissioner made a further demand for senior elected politicians to be more restrained about taking higher and higher salaries.  The PCC role attracts a salary of £85,000 but Coyne has said he would take no more than £50,000 p.a. if elected.  Tom Crone has also pledged to stay within a £50,000 p.a. cap if he is elected as mayor.

Cllr Tom Crone added

“Publishing tax returns, now and in future years, is a guarantee that senior politicians will be seen to do what they pledge to do and make it impossible for any repeat of Mayor Anderson’s unfulfilled promise (4) to take “only” £66,000 from a mayoral salary of £79,500.”

NOTES

(1) https://www.politicshome.com/news/uk/economy/taxation/news/73479/jeremy-corbyn-puts-pressure-cameron-over-publishing-tax-return
(2) http://www.liverpoolecho.co.uk/news/liverpool-news/green-party-liverpool-mayor-candidate-3347566 (17 April 2012)
(3) http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/10444466 (29 June 2010)
(4) http://www.liverpoolecho.co.uk/news/liverpool-news/liverpool-mayor-joe-anderson-rejects-3344930  (16 May 2012)